Exclusive Minds follows Eliana and Milo, from Cheating Minds, as they experience their first Valentine's Day as a couple after the events leading up to their respective divorces.

Eliana is skittish, struggling to balance her feelings for Milo with her newfound freedom, but Milo is determined to give her the perfect day. To show her how life would be different in his arms.

Until he meets Martha—the friendly neighborhood witch—and things go awry. But what presents itself as a hex, ruining his plans one after another, may turn out to be something else entirely.

Because Eliana never needed perfection, she'd already spent a decade putting on that facade and playing her part. And now, a bit of chaos may be exactly what they both need.